Sole Trader vs Limited Company: Which is Best?
Choosing between operating as a sole trader or forming a limited company is one of the most important decisions you'll make when starting a business. Each structure has distinct advantages and drawbacks that can significantly impact your taxes, liability, and administrative burden.
Quick Comparison
Sole Trader
- Simple to set up and run
- Lower accounting costs
- You keep all profits
- Unlimited personal liability
- Less tax-efficient at higher profits
Limited Company
- Limited liability protection
- More tax-efficient (dividends)
- Professional image
- More complex administration
- Higher accounting fees
Tax Implications
| Factor | Sole Trader | Limited Company |
|---|---|---|
| Income Tax | 20-45% on all profits | 19% Corporation Tax + personal tax on extraction |
| National Insurance | Class 2 + Class 4 (up to 9%) | 13.8% employer's NI on salary only |
| Dividends | Not applicable | Tax-efficient profit extraction |
| Tax Return | Self Assessment | Corporation Tax + Self Assessment |
Example: £50,000 Profit
Sole Trader
- Income Tax: £7,486
- National Insurance: £4,192
- Total Tax: £11,678
- Take home: £38,322
Limited Company
- Corporation Tax: £9,500
- Dividend Tax: £1,313
- Total Tax: £10,813
- Take home: £39,187
*Approximate figures for 2024/25. Actual savings depend on personal circumstances.
Liability Protection
Sole Trader
Unlimited liability - You and your business are legally the same entity. If the business fails:
- Your personal assets are at risk
- Creditors can pursue your home, car, savings
- You're personally liable for all business debts
Limited Company
Limited liability - The company is a separate legal entity. If the business fails:
- Your personal assets are protected
- Liability limited to share capital invested
- Creditors generally can't pursue directors personally
*Exception: Directors can be held personally liable for wrongful or fraudulent trading
Administrative Requirements
Sole Trader
- Register with HMRC for Self Assessment
- Keep records of income and expenses
- Submit annual Self Assessment tax return
- Pay Income Tax and National Insurance
Limited Company
- Register company with Companies House
- File annual accounts and confirmation statement
- Submit Corporation Tax return
- Run payroll if paying salary (RTI to HMRC)
- Maintain statutory records and minute books
- Submit personal Self Assessment if taking dividends
Which Should You Choose?
Choose Sole Trader if:
- Your profits are below £30,000-40,000 per year
- You're just starting out and want simplicity
- Your business has low risk and minimal liabilities
- You want to test your business idea without commitment
- You prefer keeping administration and costs minimal
Choose Limited Company if:
- Your profits exceed £40,000-50,000 per year
- You want to protect your personal assets
- You operate in a high-risk industry
- You want to maximize tax efficiency
- You plan to raise investment or bring in partners
- A professional image is important for your business
Can You Switch Later?
Yes! Many businesses start as sole traders and incorporate later when profits grow. The transition involves:
- Registering a new limited company with Companies House
- Transferring business assets (sometimes tax-free with incorporation relief)
- Informing customers and suppliers of the change
- Closing your sole trader records with HMRC
Not Sure Which Structure is Right for You?
Our business formation experts can analyse your specific situation and recommend the most tax-efficient structure. We'll handle all the setup and ensure you're compliant from day one.
Get Your Free Quote